Review: "The All-Soul's Faire" by Kristy Tallman

Monday, May 21, 2007

cover: the all soul's faire by kristy tallman
If you can never get enough horror, crave a thick Virginia drawl, and aren't too picky with how a book's been edited, Kristy Tallman's "The All-Soul's Faire" might be for you.  "The All-Soul's Faire" is a quick 300 page dance around suicide lookout and a moonshine-raising, Satan-worshipping, inbred disease of a family, all from the point of view of an outsider detective who's been on the local force for six months.

There is real, dark horror buried in this novel.  Once you get past the narration, the missed edits, and the characters noting how much like a horror movie everything seems, a twisted background emerges, including surreal deals with the devil and recurring orgies.  Tallman's writing seems to smooth out whenever she gets her characters into an adult situation, which happens more and more often as the plot progresses.  The protagonist spirals unwittingly into a net of lust and lost control.

I just couldn't suspend disbelief when it came to the town's apathy in the face of the unreal horrors being visited on it.  No matter how many times characters explain to the protagonist that their small town just accepts the inexplicable, nor how much back-story is brought to bear, too many excuses fell flat for me.  I didn't feel their fear, and I didn't believe they were just keeping it to themselves for the sake of being insular.

The primary plot lines and clues do get explained fairly cleanly by the end, but that largely comes in the form of a tell-all just before the /coup de grace/.  I found myself wanting new clues more frequently, and less time spent repeating the old clues in wonderment.  And I was frustrated by a couple of situations that had been built up only to be left flat.

In parting, I'd like to leave you with this short paragraph from the back cover:
I jumped, up scared as hell, not knowing if I had lost myself to a dream or if it were real.  I looked around me with my hand on my gun, ready to use it if necessary, but nothing was there, nothing at all.  The woodpecker, the deer, the wind--all of it gone--as if they had stood still with fear just as I had.  This was crazy, I thought.  I'm just stressed.  I got down off the wall and headed back down the pathway to my car.  I was almost there when I got the eerie feeling that someone was following me.

If this all sounds like your bit of shine, then pick up Kristy Tallman's "The All-Soul's Faire"
- reddit, digg, facebook, stumbleupon, etc... please! ;)
posted by kaolin

11 comments; 0 subscribers

Monday, May 21, 2007 / 11:31:38
Post a comment with the phrase "please enter me in your contest" and we'll put you in the raffle for our autographed copy and a couple pieces of swag (postcard, "admin one" bookmark). Entries will be accepted through 5/28. We'll only ship to the US.
Monday, May 21, 2007 / 12:35:12
Okay, Please enter me in your contest. I'm leery of most horror writing. I suggest that you review either Joe hill's The Heart shaped box or Jonathan Maberry's Ghost Road Blues. Both are excellent reads.
Wednesday, May 23, 2007 / 03:39:45
Please enter me into the contest
i love Horror Novels and this looks interesting to me.
Thank You.
Wednesday, May 23, 2007 / 03:42:33
"please enter me in your contest"

Your review was harsh and sarcastic and according to the other review that I read on this book, off the mark.
Wednesday, May 23, 2007 / 06:29:35
please enter me in your contest!
I want to see for myself.
Wednesday, May 23, 2007 / 08:02:43
Please enter me in your contest
Thursday, May 24, 2007 / 22:52:10
"please enter me in your contest"

Sounds like an interesting piece of horror.
Friday, May 25, 2007 / 00:40:37
Please enter me in your contest.
Tuesday, May 29, 2007 / 02:49:12
And the winner is -- Ares! Congratulations. I'll contact you shortly to verify your address. And to everyone else, there's a new review up today, if you want to enter again. :)
Tuesday, May 29, 2007 / 04:11:56
thank you so much - i have wanted to read this soooo bad
[ and yes i did enter the new contest]
Tuesday, July 17, 2007 / 06:57:17

Do you have a comment? Log in or Register; registration is quick, painless, free, and spam-free (unless you ask for it)