Review: Tavua: The White Cannibal by Rick Williamson

Sunday, November 4, 2007

Tavua: The White Cannibal

Tavua: The White Cannibal by Rick Williamson
Vorlag Angelika Hörning

ISBN: 9783938921050

Hardcover: 144 pages


Reading this book took me back to Margaret Mead's Growing Up in New Guinea, a more scholarly work that explores similar aspects of tribal culture: the kastom or taboos that have to be learnt in order to be a functioning member of the tribe.  Whereas Mead was, on the whole, a passive observer, Williamson sets out to learn the culture from the inside, determined to become a "man bush"--a full member of the tribe.  His quest brings him close to death on more than one occasion, whether from disease or from a failure to get kastom right.  It's possible that only the affection he inspires in his friends keeps him alive, as he makes blunder after blunder.

The exploration of the man bush culture is fascinating, but the book is also frustrating for what Williamson leaves out.  As a man learning the men's ways, he's apart from the women of the tribe.  He provides some fascinating details of the women's lives--for example, they're expected to give birth alone, and in silence--and there are photographs that demonstrate their importance in the tribe's day-to-day life, but we learn very little about how they spend their time, about the work they do.  From Williamson's point of view, everything important is done by men, presumably because their lifestyle is what he needs to learn so he can preserve his anatomy from dissection.

We learn about hunting and the men's rituals, but Williamson never touches, for example, on how the huts shown in his photographs are built, or by whom.  We're given intriguing insights into the justice system--kava-induced hallucinations tell one chief that a child's apparently natural death was in fact brought about by a particular man, who then must flee for his life.  There's no appeal, but he manages to stay safe for a month, and is then forgiven and welcomed back.  Evidence as we understand it counts for nothing; these people's evidence comes from the spirits and the natural world.  As the book goes on, we see Williamson becoming absorbed into the tribe's way of thinking, and much more accepting of their worldview.

At one point, he joins in a violent beating of a guest who's breached kastom.  Is it because he would otherwise be violently attacked himself--as he surely would?  Or because the breach is now as meaningful to him as to his tribal brothers?

The man bush life is harsh, and their ways appear cruel and unjust.  Women are subservient to men, and can be beaten.  Yet at the same time, children are loved and cared for.  It's a way of life adapted to their environment, and the intrusion of missionaries does not necessarily confer benefits on the people--and nor does the sudden acquisition of wealth.  Williamson tells the tale of his time among the men bush without romanticising--except perhaps towards the end.  Yet, given that Williamson dedicated years of his life to learning these people from the inside out, I can't help feeling that the book should be twice as thick.

This book would be a valuable acquisition for anyone interested in different cultures and ways of engaging with the Earth, or for a writer looking to build Fantasy or alien worlds.  I'd be very happy to keep it!
- reddit, digg, facebook, stumbleupon, etc... please! ;)
posted by Debbie

2 comments; 0 subscribers

Saturday, November 10, 2007 / 16:21:31
To win our copy of Tavua: The White Cannibal, dazzle us with your answer to the following question:

Who would you least like to eat, and why?

European Union only for this one, with apologies to our friends in other places.

Closes: 19th Nov 2007 (midnight pacific time)
Sunday, November 11, 2007 / 01:04:39
This contest has been listed with

Do you have a comment? Log in or Register; registration is quick, painless, free, and spam-free (unless you ask for it)